Search
Related Links

 

 

Informative Articles

Career and jobs: how to live with a workaholic
What turns people into workaholics? A look at the reasons why spouses spend long hours at the office...and how to bring them home and improve your relationship or marriage. There's a lot of truth to the notion that whatever...

Character Building by Designing Parents
Think carefully about what your child needs when you teach right from wrong. Research reveals 92% of high school students say they are satisfied with their own ethics and character, yet 1/4 admit stealing within the past year. (Josephson Institute...

Kippers Or Red Herrings?
Recent news has made much of parents stretching their finances to cover costs for their twenty and thirty something children. Debts and high property prices have forced many offspring to return home, tail between legs, under the attractive new...

The New Age Movement
The New Age Movement New Age - A Paradigm Shift to Divine Consciousness & a Universal Philosophy The New Age Movement (NAM) is a revival of spiritual and divine values and can be called as a Divine Regeneration Movement. New Age Philosophy has...

What is Coaching? What Do Coaches Do?
In a relatively new field with few barriers to entry, there are a lot of questions. Is coaching some kind of therapy by another name? Is it like talking to your best friend? Why would someone hire a coach? What do you use a coach for? What might a...

 
The Debate about Cloning - Part I

How to cope with your abuser?

Sometimes it looks hopeless. There are two types of cloning. One involves harvesting stem cells from embryos ("therapeutic cloning"). These are the biological equivalent of a template. They can develop into any kind of mature functional cell and thus help cure many degenerative and auto-immune diseases.

The other kind of cloning is much derided in popular culture - and elsewhere - as the harbinger of a Brave, New World. A nucleus from any cell of a donor is embedded in an egg whose own nucleus has been removed. The egg is then implanted in a woman's womb and a cloned baby is born nine months later. Biologically, the cloned infant is a replica of the donor.

Cloning is often confused with other advances in bio-medicine and bio-engineering - such as genetic selection. It cannot - in itself - be used to produce "perfect humans" or select sex or other traits. Hence, some of the arguments against cloning are either specious or fuelled by ignorance.

It is true, though, that cloning, used in conjunction with other bio-technologies, raises serious bio-ethical questions. Scare scenarios of humans cultivated in sinister labs as sources of spare body parts, "designer babies", "master races", or "genetic sex slaves" - formerly the preserve of B sci-fi movies - have invaded mainstream discourse.

Still, cloning touches upon Mankind's most basic fears and hopes. It invokes the most intractable ethical and moral dilemmas. As an inevitable result, the debate is often more passionate than informed.

I. Right to Life Arguments

According to cloning's detractors, the nucleus removed from the egg could otherwise have developed into a human being. Thus, removing the nucleus amounts to murder.

It is a fundamental principle of most moral theories that all human beings have a right to life. The existence of a right implies obligations or duties of third parties towards the right-holder. One has a right AGAINST other people. The fact that one possesses a certain right - prescribes to others certain obligatory behaviours and proscribes certain acts or omissions. This Janus-like nature of rights and duties as two sides of the same ethical coin - creates great confusion. People often and easily confuse rights and their attendant duties or obligations with the morally decent, or even with the morally permissible. What one MUST do as a result of another's right - should never be confused with one SHOULD or OUGHT to do morally (in the absence of a right).

The right to life has eight distinct strains:

IA. The right to be brought to life

IB. The right to be born

IC. The right to have one's life maintained

ID. The right not to be killed

IE. The right to have one's life saved

IF. The right to save one's life (erroneously limited to the right to self-defence)

IG. The right to terminate one's life

IH. The right to have one's life terminated

IA. The Right to be Brought to Life

Only living people have rights. There is a debate whether an egg is a living person - but there can be no doubt that it exists. Its rights - whatever they are - derive from the fact that it exists and that it has the potential to develop life. The right to be brought to life (the right to become or to be) pertains to a yet non-alive entity and, therefore, is null and void. Had this right existed, it would have implied an obligation or duty to give life to the unborn and the not yet conceived. No such duty or obligation exist.

IB. The Right to be Born

The right to be born crystallizes at the moment of voluntary and intentional fertilization. If a scientist knowingly and intentionally causes in vitro fertilization for the explicit and express purpose of creating an embryo - then the resulting fertilized egg has a right to mature and be born. Furthermore, the born child has all the rights a child has against his parents: food, shelter, emotional nourishment, education, and so on.

It is debatable whether such rights of the fetus and, later, of the child, exist if there was no positive act of fertilization - but, on the contrary, an act which prevents possible fertilization, such as the removal of the nucleus (see IC below).

IC. The Right to Have One's Life Maintained

Does one have the right to maintain one's life and prolong them at other people's expense? Does one have the right to use other people's bodies, their property, their time, their resources and to deprive them of pleasure, comfort, material possessions, income, or any other thing?

The answer is yes and no.

No one has a right to sustain his or her life, maintain, or prolong them at another INDIVIDUAL's expense (no matter how minimal and insignificant the sacrifice required is). Still, if a contract has been signed - implicitly or explicitly - between the parties, then such a right may crystallize in the


contract and create corresponding duties and obligations, moral, as well as legal.

Example:

No fetus has a right to sustain its life, maintain, or prolong them at his mother's expense (no matter how minimal and insignificant the sacrifice required of her is). Still, if she signed a contract with the fetus - by knowingly and willingly and intentionally conceiving it - such a right has crystallized and has created corresponding duties and obligations of the mother towards her fetus.

On the other hand, everyone has a right to sustain his or her life, maintain, or prolong them at SOCIETY's expense (no matter how major and significant the resources required are). Still, if a contract has been signed - implicitly or explicitly - between the parties, then the abrogation of such a right may crystallize in the contract and create corresponding duties and obligations, moral, as well as legal.

Example:

Everyone has a right to sustain his or her life, maintain, or prolong them at society's expense. Public hospitals, state pension schemes, and police forces may be required to fulfill society's obligations - but fulfill them it must, no matter how major and significant the resources are. Still, if a person volunteered to join the army and a contract has been signed between the parties, then this right has been thus abrogated and the individual assumed certain duties and obligations, including the duty or obligation to give up his or her life to society.

ID. The Right not to be Killed

Every person has the right not to be killed unjustly. What constitutes "just killing" is a matter for an ethical calculus in the framework of a social contract.

But does A's right not to be killed include the right against third parties that they refrain from enforcing the rights of other people against A? Does A's right not to be killed preclude the righting of wrongs committed by A against others - even if the righting of such wrongs means the killing of A?

Not so. There is a moral obligation to right wrongs (to restore the rights of other people). If A maintains or prolongs his life ONLY by violating the rights of others and these other people object to it - then A must be killed if that is the only way to right the wrong and re-assert their rights.

This is doubly true if A's existence is, at best, debatable. An egg does not a human being make. Removal of the nucleus is an important step in life-saving research. An unfertilized egg has no rights at all.

IE. The Right to Have One's Life Saved

There is no such right as there is no corresponding moral obligation or duty to save a life. This "right" is a demonstration of the aforementioned muddle between the morally commendable, desirable and decent ("ought", "should") and the morally obligatory, the result of other people's rights ("must").

In some countries, the obligation to save life is legally codified. But while the law of the land may create a LEGAL right and corresponding LEGAL obligations - it does not always or necessarily create a moral or an ethical right and corresponding moral duties and obligations.

IF. The Right to Save One's Own Life

The right to self-defence is a subset of the more general and all-pervasive right to save one's own life. One has the right to take certain actions or avoid taking certain actions in order to save his or her own life.

It is generally accepted that one has the right to kill a pursuer who knowingly and intentionally intends to take one's life. It is debatable, though, whether one has the right to kill an innocent person who unknowingly and unintentionally threatens to take one's life.

IG. The Right to Terminate One's Life

See "The Murder of Oneself".

IH. The Right to Have One's Life Terminated

The right to euthanasia, to have one's life terminated at will, is restricted by numerous social, ethical, and legal rules, principles, and considerations. In a nutshell - in many countries in the West one is thought to has a right to have one's life terminated with the help of third parties if one is going to die shortly anyway and if one is going to be tormented and humiliated by great and debilitating agony for the rest of one's remaining life if not helped to die. Of course, for one's wish to be helped to die to be accommodated, one has to be in sound mind and to will one's death knowingly, intentionally, and forcefully.

Sam Vaknin is the author of Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited and After the Rain - How the West Lost the East. He is a columnist for Central Europe Review, PopMatters, and eBookWeb , a United Press International (UPI) Senior Business Correspondent, and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory Bellaonline, and Suite101 .

Visit Sam's Web site at http://samvak.tripod.com


 

Ethics Updates Home Page. Moral theory; relativism; pluralism ...
Designed primarily to be used by ethics instructors and their students to provide updates on current literature, both popular and professional.
ethics.sandiego.edu
 
Ethics Resource Center: Celebrating 85 Years of Ethics Surveying ...
The Ethics Resource Center (ERC) is a non-profit, non-partisan research and survey organization in Washington, DC, dedicated to the study and promotion of ...
www.ethics.org
 
Ethics - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
One form of applied ethics applies normative ethical theories to specific ... There are several sub-branches of applied ethics examining the ethical ...
en.wikipedia.org
 
Ethics
Quarterly international journal of moral, political, and legal philosophy. Edited by John Deigh, and published by the University of Chicago Press.
www.journals.uchicago.edu
 
Ethics, Electronic Edition
(ET ISSUES AVAILABLE ONLY SINCE VOLUME 112 NO 1). Help with Searching the Ethics Electronic Edition. Help with Access to the Ethics Electronic Edition ...
www.journals.uchicago.edu
 
Ethics [Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy]
Describes the field and its division in metaethics, normative ethics, and applied ethics. By James Fieser.
www.iep.utm.edu
 
JSTOR: Ethics
JSTOR provides a digital archive of the print version of Ethics . ... Founded in 1890, Ethics is an international journal of moral, political, ...
www.jstor.org
 
Institute for Global Ethics | Home Page
An independent, nonprofit, nonsectarian, and nonpartisan organization dedicated to promoting awareness and discussion of global ethics.
www.globalethics.org
 
Business Ethics
Business Ethics Articles from George S. May International Company ... Links to other e-business ethics articles can also be found at this site. ...
www.web-miner.com
 
The Online Ethics Center for Engineering & Science
The Online Ethics Center for Engineering and Science mission is to provide engineers, scientists, and science and engineering students with resources for ...
onlineethics.org
 
Title Page: Spinoza's Ethics / Elwes Translation
Ethics Demonstrated in Geometric Order AND DIVIDED INTO FIVE PARTS, ... This edition of the Ethics utilizes internal hypertext coding to faciilitate the ...
www.mtsu.edu
 
APA Ethics Office: Ethics Information
American Psychological Association sanctioned resources for ethics in psychology, including guidelines for human and animal studies, rules and procedures, ...
www.apa.org
 
Aristotle's Ethics (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy)
Discussion of Aristotle's ethical views; by Richard Kraut.
plato.stanford.edu
 
IEEE Code of Ethics
Code of ethics for members.
www.ieee.org
 
st james ethics centre - imagine a more ethical world ...
Not-for-profit organisation which provides a non-judgemental forum for the promotion and exploration of ethics.
www.ethics.org.au
 
Markkula Center for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara University ...
The Markkula Center for Applied Ethics at Santa Clara University is one of the preeminent centers for research and dialogue on ethical issues in critical ...
www.scu.edu
 
Poynter Online - Ethics
How Poynter developed ethics guidelines for our own publications. ... In creating online ethics guidelines, Poynter asks for your feedback. By Bob Steele ...
www.poynter.org
 
ACM: Code of Ethics
Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct.
www.acm.org
 
US Senate Ethics Committee
Investigates allegations of misconduct by members, and recommends disciplinary action to the full Senate.
ethics.senate.gov
 
LegalEthics.com: The Intersection of Ethics and the Law
Legalethics.com offers cases, codes, opinions, articles, links, and other reference material relating to ethics and the law.
www.legalethics.com
 
 

 

Content Menu
  • 10 great websites for women

  • 10 key elements when supporting the dually diagnosed

  • 10 reasons why consumer opinion is low for carpet cleaners and other service professionals

  • 10 reasons why public opinion is low for professionals who do service work in your home

  • 10 secrets to know youre a good working parent to your kids

  • 12 signs it is really time to leave your job

  • 21 secrets of self made millionaires

  • 25 valuable phone numbers for small businesses success

  • 3 vital steps to prevent your lungs from being your furance filter this fall

  • 5x2 great reasons to go for online dating

  • 5 things you need to know before deciding on a certification training

  • 8 steps to financially intelligent parenting

  • 911 the call that counts

  • adult dating friend or foeyour sex life and the internet

  • alternative clothing for babies

  • animal ethics

  • an important lesson for americas future business leaders

  • are your children ready for school

  • are you speaking the same language in your office

  • are you unknowingly poisoning your family

  • aspergers syndrome diagnosis should i tell my child

  • attaining a debt free lifestyle

  • a principled plan

  • a years worth of character training to last a lifetime

  • back when i was a kid

  • beyond the pain and stigma to healing

  • bodily attributes

  • boy do we get the garbage

  • bringing spirituality to the workplace

  • buying a home after bankruptcy beware of shady subprime mortgage lenders

  • career and jobs how to live with a workaholic

  • cathars courtly love and history

  • celebrate your senses an evening scented garden

  • celebrating fathers

  • character building by designing parents

  • children patriots

  • christian in the workplace pii how to deal with co workers

  • common pitfalls of plastic surgery

  • communication then and now

  • conscience

  • considering daycare consider the pros and cons

  • conspiracy of silence

  • cosmeceuticals the new wave in skin care solutions

  • dealing with a gassy baby

  • decency

  • determinants of success revisited again

  • dog food which diet is best for dogs

  • donald trump and the apprentice rules applied to dating

  • donald trump rules applied to dating

  • dont blame the government for americas obesity

  • dont forgive infidelity

  • dont let someone else define who you are

  • do you know the alternatives

  • do you want to know how monogamy came to be

  • eclectic paths to integration series psychological models freud

  • essence of infidelity

  • evangelical skepticism pursuing your right to be wrong

  • even as thy soul prospereth

  • e book on russian women part 1

  • facing the homeschool super mom

  • family incest and law

  • fight the disease

  • genealogy

  • get unstuck use the power of volunteering

  • give your child the gift of self esteem

  • growing good people

  • hair replacement and restoration techniques

  • has the cure for cancer been here all along

  • hedwigs angry inch

  • help your child help your community

  • her last day in court

  • hold a charity birthday party for your child

  • holistic health

  • home for the holidays

  • hot new designers you have to know about

  • how important is it to stand apart from others in an interview and how difficult is it

  • how public schools assault parents values

  • how the challenge of single parenting affects your decision to divorce

  • how to align your goals for success

  • how to be a christian in the workplace

  • how to buy discounted designers shoes

  • how to choose a marriage counselor

  • how to choose a repair shop without getting ripped off

  • how to choose the right man using your eq

  • how to choose the right marriage counselor

  • how to develop a winning attitude

  • how to have a charity birthday party for your child

  • how to recognize elder abuse and protect its victim

  • how to safely buy a diamond online part 2 of 3

  • index

  • in the beginning

  • irresistible

  • is god trying to tell you something

  • is it lust or love how to tell the difference

  • is this the career choice of the future

  • is your teen driving you crazy

  • i care but not that much

  • jesus autobiography

  • just what is colic and does my baby have it

  • kippers or red herrings

  • lady will power its now or never an eq tale

  • leadership is power test your ethics

  • left work to be a stay at home mom so why do you feel like you are missing out

  • lifecare communities commitment to quality

  • live on forever or why you need an ethical will

  • living the rollover life a mandate for marketplace ministers

  • living wills make final wishes known

  • materialism and individuals

  • medical billing and coding profession

  • medical records can i see them or not

  • mentor who needs a mentor

  • misplaced allegiance

  • mommy baby burping and nighttime feeding

  • more effective communication with children part 3

  • movin on taking transhumanism in stride

  • mrsa the silent killer are you at risk

  • my father who art in heaven

  • overcoming the fear of money

  • parenting troubled teens

  • parents you can do something about professional sports ethics

  • planning a babyshower

  • planning a baby shower

  • positive aikido the book

  • racism and you

  • review unbridled injustice authored by ellie boatman

  • rivers rapids bears oh my

  • rotator

  • rush limbaugh victim perp or none of the above part 1

  • second time around the block

  • sex and the soul

  • shirley temple stories

  • shopping be wary

  • should children work

  • should i give up me to not lose you

  • should i tell my child of their aspergers syndrome diagnosis

  • simplifying simple

  • single parenting how the challenge of single parenting affects your decision to divorce

  • society in deep denial sexual child abuse

  • sports psychology guidelines for sports parents

  • start raising successful children

  • stress and depression are killing us

  • stupid advice

  • sucessful aging

  • synthetic hair extensions create choice hair styles for fashion and hair loss clients

  • take charge of your job search 12 steps to success

  • terri schiavos gift

  • the big secret of ameriplan usa

  • the debate about cloning

  • the debate about cloning part i

  • the debate about cloning part ii

  • the essence of infidelity

  • the ethical responsible puppy buyer

  • the first thing on your to do list

  • the ideas in your head will rule your world

  • the importance of mothers

  • the last day of who cares

  • the low eq way to choose the right man for you

  • the manifestations of self

  • the mother harnessing an onslaught

  • the myth of mental illness

  • the new age movement

  • the one important secret of making more money easily

  • the pet food ingredient game

  • the shattered identity

  • time for connection

  • turf wars author landlord offers a few words of advice for tenants

  • two valuable ways to enhance your success

  • types of russian marriage agencies

  • uncontested divorce how thinking about an uncontested divorce figures into your decision about divorce

  • ways fathers can invest in their children

  • ways father s can invest in their children

  • whats causing my depression and fatigue

  • whats up with the bad reading

  • what can i do to improve my job interviewing skills

  • what does tech have to do with womens rights

  • what girls were expected to know

  • what is coaching what do coaches do

  • when compassion leaves

  • when the kids wont listen

  • where are all the good contractors

  • whose fault was it

  • why do we lack character

  • why many prefer online dating over traditional one

  • wny work with a certified emotional intelligence coach

  • won ton or kreplach how we raise children in our chinese jewish family

  • your introverted child is unique

  • your mission field at work