Search
Related Links

 

 

Informative Articles

Believing in Jesus is NOT a Religion, and God is NOT a Christian
What are the major misconceptions by ignorant atheists [Less than 4% of the world population (www.adherents.com)]? The ‘fact’ that we are primarily body, and spirituality comes second is the first and most important mistake of all with the...

God's one government has two branches!
The Sabbath-keeping Church of God (that remains faithful to the plain truth of the Bible that Herbert W. Armstrong taught) has heard a lot about government, but many seem to have forgotten that God's ONE government has TWO branches: Church...

Islam is not the problem
Islam is not the problem Many people on religious paths are lousy advertisements for God. I'm sure that if there were some divine psychometric or behavioural screening mechanism in place, many wouldn't be permitted to be card-carrying...

One Day at A Time
If just for today, Lord, I’ll keep my eyes and heart in tune to Your ever-loving presence. I’ll walk with You and glean upon Your every word ... be ready to go, ready to stay, and bask in the fullness of Your day. If just for today, Lord, I’ll...

The God in Islam
Many secular persons deny the presence of the God. I am trying here to convince them that there is a God who has created the universe. Many secular persons will argue that the God is unseen and they believe only in what they see. The God is...

 
Christ and Culture (Part 1)

Christ and Culture Part 1

The conflict between Christ and culture is not new and neither is it rare. It is a daily occurrence as the boundaries are blurred and the culture develops. Christians have been viewed more often than not as subversive because of a belief that they are destined for more than just a human destiny. Many times they have paid a high price for it and continue to do so, from the early Christian martyrs of Rome to those who refuse to bend their beliefs to the desires of a communist state. In many nations of the modern world the underground church is still being persecuted.

Such cases are disturbing but expected. In many nations there are overt and covert attempts to silence religion, that is out of favour, from being expressed in public institutions. Religious views are being marginalised and reduced to impotent fairy tales better suited to children's bedrooms before a good night kiss, or perhaps some trivial, private and quiet hobby like stamp collecting. Religion is seen as an activity not befitting an intelligent public-spirited adult.
Religion is seen as a past-time not a lifestyle. The issue is very much current as well as historical. To tackle question of Christ and culture we should clearly define Christ and culture.

Christ as the Son of God points us away from the many values man tends to prioritise and to the one God who is truly good. Yet at the same time, Jesus is a mediator between God and man, in Jesus we see God's love for man as well as man's love for God. Christ in us is a joining of the two. This duality in Christ leads us to a corresponding duality of expression of Christ in us.

Our faith has both a vertical dimension (directed to God the Father through Christ in us) and a horizontal dimension (directed through Christ in us to our neighbour). Any adequate address of Christ and culture needs to emphasise both that we are seated with Christ in heavenly places, above and beyond the world and hate the world, in that we find no cause for identity in it, and at the same time God in fact gave His life for the world as a result of His love for mankind, and enjoins us to do the same.

We hate the sin but love the sinner. Culture comprises of language, habits, ideas, beliefs, customs, social organisation, inherited artefacts, technical processes, and values.

So what happens when Christ and culture collide? How are we to deal with Christ and culture in daily life. Here are a few ideas of how Christians have often dealt with this issue.

1. Christ is against culture
The most radical answer is that Christ is against culture. God is the sole authority for the Christian, presenting Christ and culture as an either/or choice. If we follow Christ we must reject any loyalty to culture.

Do not love the world or anything in the world. If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him (1 John 2:15).

Some would argue that the prince of this world is Satan therefore to choose culture is to choose loyalty to the devil.

All state obligations are against the conscience of a Christian - the oath of allegiance, taxes, law proceedings and military service. Christians in this view are encouraged to separate themselves from the culture, either individually as Tolstoy did, or corporately as the Mennonites have done, as a monastic community.

The integrity of those adhering to this option is shown firstly, in their willingness to suffer martyrdom in some cases under evil governments, and secondly, in the social reforms they provoke.

The problem with this option is that it is impossible to separate oneself from culture as it permeates our thinking and language, in fact it is as much around us as it is in our heads. Though it may be possible to keep some evil aspects of culture out of our communities by separatism, we cannot rid ourselves of our own predisposition to sin.

If the Amish live apart from state institutions or from mainstream technology and consumerism, all they succeed in doing is creating sub-cultures that while they may be counterculture, never attain to acultural status. The fact that a monastic lifestyle often required many rules and forms of discipline is proof enough of the inherent tendency of man to fall into old patterns of sin. Because of this, separatist groups tend to adhere to grades of holiness that can only be maintained through works. Claiming that the monastic life lead to greater holiness is why Luther said that it was not only unnecessary but, if it was chosen for this reason, it would become an institution of the devil!

Separatism also only emphasises Christ's role in drawing us away from culture (the vertical dimension) but ignores God's role in our continued relationship with culture (the horizontal dimension). If Tolstoy was right, a Christian should pay no taxes, something that Jesus Christ said we should do. Jesus also tells us to love our neighbours, who are for the most, part found in mainstream culture where practical works of love have to be culturally relevant to the people who need God's love to understand it as such.

Christ even seems to reject separatism in the parable of the Good Samaritan. The Samaritan crossed cultural norms to help whereas the priest and Levite for the sake of holiness kept themselves apart from him. The Samaritan is held up as our moral guide in the story.

In order for culture to be rejected in favour of Christ, logic requires that


God Himself is not a part of culture. This would make sense if we only knew God as solely spiritual, but we also know Him as incarnate. He shows His nature in creation, which expresses His attributes, in Jesus by incarnation as a specific and very cultural human being (Hebrews 2:14-18), as well as in believers today through the indwelling Spirit of Christ in every believer. Since we are to follow Christ in all things, we should follow him in the cultural dimension as well.

2. Christ is of Culture
Cultural Christians claim that Christ is to be understood as the highest aspiration and fulfilment of culture. So it is possible to affirm both Christ and culture and to deny any necessary opposition between the two.

Culture can be interpreted through Christ, where the elements of culture that are most complimentary to Jesus' work and person are the best; as are those things that can be understood of God through culture.

In this way they are most accommodating, reconciling Christianity with what appears to be the greatest achievements of culture. The early church had it's share of Hellenizers, Judaizers and Gnostics who joined Christ to their mystical philosophy, and in the same way today there are many who attempt to reduce Christianity to practical morality and Jesus Christ to one of many great moral teachers.

The error of this option is equal to, but also in direct opposition to separatism in that it is so concentrated on the world that while focused on the horizontal dimension it ignores the vertical dimension. Thus putting very little emphasis on grace or eternity aand the afterlife, and producing a self-reliant form of humanism.

Ultimately this deifies man and humanises God, creating theology in man's image through connecting Christ with some cultural movement one wishes to endorse. So we have Christianity AND homosexuality, Christianity AND new psychology, Christianity AND Veganism, Christianity AND political correctness or Christianity AND any other syncretism you could care to mention.

So we end up thinking that some aspect of God can be found in a same-sex relationship and the acceptance of homosexual rights. Political correctness in a culture takes preference over what the Bible may say about a subject. And we find that as the horizontal dimension gets distorted the vertical dimension gets ignored. We listen to the spirit of the age more than the Holy Spirit.

There is one aspect of accommodation that is relevant to us. When communicating the gospel we do need to adapt it to our audience, that is, while not compromising the message of the gospel we should present it incarnate so that it translates into the understanding of the people-group. We need to present a contextualised Christianity, not syncretism. Paul adapted his delivery dependant on whether his audience was Jewish, gentile, Roman or Greek in order to make it relevant to their way of thinking. Jesus did the same with His parables. By being cultural chameleons we can take the gospel message and find culturally relevant clothing to make it relevant. This is the incarnation of Christ in the prevailing culture.

3. Christ is above culture
In this view Christ and culture are synthesised. This option says that culture has good in it since God created the world and though it was distorted by the fall it is not entirely evil, it still has attributes of God in it. So in this view we cannot say "either Christ or culture" because we are dealing with God in both cases and we also must not say "both Christ and culture" as if there was no distinction between them.

Thomas Aquinas believed that the church is simultaneously in and beyond the world, leading people to salvation in heaven, while affirming the best in this world's culture. He believed that God has purposes in the temporal as well as the eternal realms.
This option affirms a stable relationship between church and state as well as encouraging the conservation of values and authority. The church should back up the government's authority to maintain order. So in the earthly as well as in the Heavenly realms there is a hierarchical organisation in church and state.

There is one King over the temporal and the eternal and we have practical solutions for living the Christian life within culture and gives incentive for government and education as well as encouraging academic principles.
The danger is that the church will socially stagnate and fossilise with it's emphasis on values and authority, it may perpetuate dictatorships and prevent legislative reform. If respect for temporal authority is too great, there is a danger that man made laws will undermine God's law.

There is also no separation of church and state, leading to prohibition or the evil of forcing people to change their beliefs by relying on the sword rather than the word. The integration of church and state to make people believe things is evil and pretty impossible because changing someone's behaviour produces a hypocrite, and even though you can change someone's behaviour through force, it still does not mean you have changed their belief.

Please see the other parts of this article..... Christ and Culture


About the Author

Aleck Cartwright is an author, journalist, graphic designer, missionary, teacher and Christian who runs his own website called www.god-life.com, he writes on and addresses many different topics and issues from a Biblical world-view.

 

Religion - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Religion may be defined as the presence of a belief in the sacred or the holy. ... The development of religion is therefore the course of religions aligning ...
en.wikipedia.org
 
religion online
Full texts by religious scholars. Topics include Bible, Theology, Ethics, Church and Society, Communication, Cultural Studies, Homiletics, Missions, ...
www.religion-online.org
 
Religion and Spirituality in the Yahoo! Directory
Yahoo! reviewed these sites and found them related to Religion and Spirituality.
dir.yahoo.com
 
Yahoo! - Document Not Found
Document Not Found. The document you requested was not found. The category you are trying to reach may have moved. To find a relocated category, ...
dir.yahoo.com
 
Virtual Religion Index
has moved! It is now located at. http://virtualreligion.net/vri/. Note the change of domain & Please notify the source of the link that landed you here. ...
religion.rutgers.edu
 
Religious News and Information
The latest news and coverage from the world of religion. From across the globe to here in Los Angeles, the Los Angeles Time covers the most pertinent news ...
www.latimes.com
 
World Religions Religion Statistics Geography Church Statistics
Resources for research into world religions, large and (very) small. Includes links to websites, research papers, statistics, and specialized search ...
www.adherents.com
 
BBC - Religion & Ethics
News, features and weekly summary about religion in the UK. Includes information about religions, ethics issues, and BBC religious TV and radio programming.
www.bbc.co.uk
 
BBC - Religion & Ethics - Religions
An introduction to many of the religions of the world. Includes Jainism, Shinto, Sikhism, Rastafari, Paganism, and many others.
www.bbc.co.uk
 
Open Directory - Society: Religion and Spirituality
Kids and Teens: People and Society: Religion and Spirituality (307) ... World Religions and 101 Cults - Contains descriptions and personal commentary of ...
dmoz.org
 
Google Directory - Society > Religion and Spirituality
Kids and Teens > People and Society > Religion and Spirituality (347) ... Contains descriptions and personal commentary of religions, cults, sects, ...
www.google.com
 
Promoting religious understanding, tolerance and freedom.
Conflicts, evolution, science & religion evaluating each other ... "Study of the world's religions will lead to an understanding of religious diversity; ...
www.religioustolerance.org
 
Religious Studies Page
Gene Thursby's extensive collection of information and links for the study and interpretation of religions. Categories include religious traditions, ...
www.clas.ufl.edu
 
Dallas Morning News | News for Dallas, Texas | Religion
Religion blog: DMN writers and editors explore issues of faith, spirituality and values ... Religion links: Alphabetical list of religious and spiritual ...
www.dallasnews.com
 
Free Religion Ecards, Religion Greeting Cards, Religion Greetings ...
More of Religion ... Home : Religion Greetings ... Food And Drink | Gifts | Invitations | Kids | Love | Music | Pets | Religion | Specials | Sports | Stay ...
cards.123greetings.com
 
Religion -- Philadelphia Inquirer
Most evangelicals now live in China, South Korea, India, Africa and Latin America, where they are transforming their religion. In various ways, they are ...
www.philly.com
 
Religion | The WWW Virtual Library
Religions and belief systems (ancient and contemporary), religious history, mythology, ethics and humanism. this resource in English is indexed under: ...
vlib.org
 
Religion - washingtonpost.com
We explore matters of faith and religion on the first Sunday of each month. ... Religion Online Chats. Thursday, Nov. 16, 11 a.m. ET: Faiths Condemn Gay Sex ...
www.washingtonpost.com
 
allAfrica.com: Religion
All over Africa, religion is big business. In East Africa, I am particularly impressed by the rate of its growth in Uganda. Uganda is also the country in ...
allafrica.com
 
Error: Invalid story key (C3,20061205,,612040318,AR).
Obituaries · -- Death Notices · Schools · Detroit History. Nation/World. Nation/World · Politics/Gov · -- Election · Health · Religion · Technology. Sports ...
detnews.com
 
 

 

Content Menu
  • 7 words americans should stop using until further investigation

  • abandon religion

  • abaris rabbi the druid

  • about basic teachings of christian faith christians

  • about being a christian

  • about the mark of the beast

  • abraham the dreamer an erotic and sacred love story explores turbulent love triangle

  • african arab muslims teach abraham was black

  • all the same

  • amos and social justice part 2

  • antichrist and the gog magog war

  • an account of jesus temptation

  • an opportunity to turn

  • are you building your own cistern

  • are you where god is

  • ask your angels for help prospering

  • astrology and vedic yajnas rituals in hindu religion

  • as america turns against god

  • author examines complexities of the holy land from a personal perspective

  • awe perfect

  • a commonsense guide to exorcism

  • a common sense approach to religious freedom

  • a house of prayer for all peoples

  • a little bit of something

  • a man of his word

  • a motivating factor

  • a promise fulfilled

  • a psychic confesses

  • a spiritual solution

  • a storm is coming

  • a time for every season

  • baby steps

  • bang

  • bang bang your dead

  • beauty and ecumenicism

  • behold the prince of persia get ready for war with iran

  • believing in jesus is not a religion and god is not a christian

  • between hevan and hell pt 2

  • blessings and lessons of life

  • born to bear witness

  • call no man father

  • can you walk the walk

  • captives of a concept anatomy of an illusion

  • celebrating advent as a family

  • checking our foundation

  • chicken soup with chopsticks excerpts from chapter one

  • christians barred from praying upon jerusalems temple mount

  • christians the minority

  • christmas

  • christ and culture part 1

  • christ in you means no degrees to spirituality

  • come as you are

  • come home

  • comparative religion 101 what they wont tell you in that class

  • consequences

  • conspiracy theorist

  • contemplation

  • controversial role of religious scholars in pakistan

  • counting them happy

  • dating a non christian

  • david ben ariel faces the aryan nations

  • dealing with heart disease

  • dear satan

  • did you inherit your religion

  • does belief in god better your health

  • do angels have names

  • do people see visions anymore

  • esthers zeal the feast of purim

  • expect persecution for speaking the plain truth

  • fall of a nation

  • fornication

  • freedom of access to israel

  • freedom of religion

  • from defeat to victory

  • from orphans to royalty

  • fundamental church failures

  • genuine islam

  • giving credit where credit is due

  • gnosis the secret of solomons temple revealed

  • godless britain

  • gods church must warn the world

  • gods festivals

  • gods one government has two branches

  • god beings in the making

  • god first

  • god in america rip

  • god is not mocked

  • grace for grace

  • hair of women

  • hang on

  • hasten to fast

  • hermeneutics

  • hinduism is source of spiritual energy

  • hindus and their satanic religion

  • history of palestine

  • hitlers positive christianity

  • hitler was a catholic

  • holding onto your peace

  • holy terror

  • hoomana hawaiian gods

  • hypocrites enjoying the freedom of religion

  • if i were called

  • if jesus never came

  • index

  • intelligent design has god turned the tables on evolution

  • intercessory prayer for the pentagon and employees

  • interfaith wedding ceremony ideas

  • in everything you do

  • in the worst of all places

  • islamic world domination

  • islam as a religion of tolerance and moderation

  • islam in the workplace suggested practice for hr personnel

  • islam is not the problem

  • islam religion defines character trait

  • israel work history worldwide church of god

  • is buddhism a religion

  • is christianity losing america

  • is god prejudiced

  • is your life significant

  • its time to retire the christ killer charge

  • jain religion as a world religion

  • jain religion is not to follow

  • jesus and the gnostic cathars

  • jesus christ one can reach god only through him is this statement correct

  • jesus pbuh the pharisee

  • jihad

  • john paul the honest

  • john tetzel scaring the hell out of christians

  • joshian theism i e superultramodern theism

  • knowing them by their fruit

  • kundalini awakening definition and the path

  • law vs liberty

  • legalism

  • lessons from james

  • let there be peace

  • listen for their voices

  • love never fails

  • l ron hubbard jr blows the whistle

  • mahavira 24th tirthankara of jainism his teachings and essence

  • make not my fathers house a house of merchandise

  • making things harder

  • meditation a great catholic bonus

  • meeting jesus in meditation

  • meet his sacrifice

  • meet jesus sacrifice

  • mohammad

  • moslem america

  • moslem america conclusion

  • moslem america part 2

  • navigating the catechism

  • octopussy

  • old world perishes in flood

  • one day at a time

  • one of satans tricks

  • only two paths

  • onward christian soldiers

  • operation save israel

  • pass it on a rule for good bible interpretation

  • pope to sweep europe off its feet

  • poster boy john kerry

  • predestination

  • prioritize your life for success

  • prophecies of the end times

  • pure religion

  • race matters

  • real leadership stability in a sea of change

  • reconstructionism dominionism warfare theology

  • reforming the state church solutions for the church inc 501c3 problem

  • religion

  • religion and disasters

  • religion and science

  • religion and spirituality what differentiates religion from spirituality

  • religion and techology

  • religion as a method of explanation

  • religion is ignorance

  • religion politics the landmark ruling of justice moore vs the united states

  • religion s hes wrong im right

  • religion there it is

  • religious dating traditions and values

  • revelations a study conclusion

  • revelations a study section 13

  • revelations a study section 6

  • rotator

  • salvation army not just a religion a charity worth giving to

  • sammy davis junior found religion

  • scientology the new cult of lies

  • second coming of jesus christ revalation

  • seek god

  • self realization how it can be achieved within ones life time

  • seven truths perceiving this war differently

  • sheik palazzi and the apostle paul

  • should christians judge

  • smartville

  • spiritualisms tools and the last days

  • spirituality vs religion

  • spirituality vs technology a war of ideals

  • spirituality what it truly means to you

  • spiritual belief

  • spiritual prosperity

  • spiritual skepticisms

  • state favors result in state control of the church

  • stop defending your faith

  • superultramodern religion sr

  • swimming upstream

  • terror the lost war

  • then what is the real holy spirit

  • theology hollywood style

  • the amazing destructive power of tradition

  • the angel metatron

  • the apolitic nature of revelations pt 2

  • the apolitic nature of revelations pt 3

  • the apolitic nature of the revelations pt 1

  • the athiests enigma

  • the black pope part one

  • the blind village and the elephant

  • the christian muslim conflict from scripture to religions

  • the church choir

  • the covenant gods relationship to jews israelites and gentiles

  • the crucifixion and escapism theories of karl marx and mircea eliade

  • the de mystified logos john 1 as it was meant to be read

  • the essence of worship part 2

  • the fear of death

  • the god in islam

  • the good and the bad

  • the green cross

  • the holy land as a human shape

  • the kolbrin ancient warnings of modern threats

  • the late great planet earth pt 1

  • the lost pt 2

  • the new age movement

  • the oracles of god

  • the origin of religions

  • the passion of the christ who really killed jesus

  • the pendant of phenice

  • the pharisees

  • the plain truth about the lost ten tribes and why you need to know

  • the plight of pew warmers

  • the power of love

  • the rise and fall of babylon

  • the satanic verses of bhagavad gita

  • the simple enormity of catholicism

  • the story of one soul so far

  • the taxation of religion

  • the temple of love unites every religion and every country as one

  • the truth about jehovah and the madness of organized religions

  • the two most important commandments love

  • the united states of europe is a joke

  • the use of mysticism in the song of songs

  • the zodiac signs of the end times events

  • think about it

  • thomas paine jefferson

  • thou shalt not

  • three stages of soul

  • tommy said intelligent design in school today

  • to the highest bidder part 2

  • to the unknown god

  • two kinds of religions

  • two thousand years later the passion of the christ

  • two witnesses to testify in jerusalem against europe

  • t e n interview with god

  • u n resolution 181 blueprint of the beast

  • viewing the journey as the reward in sports and spirituality

  • walking in dark places

  • we are made to resist

  • what are angels

  • what is islam part 2

  • what is islam part 4

  • what is the spiritual path

  • what is truth

  • what kingdom builders know

  • what that 70s show taught me about christianity

  • when a good man becomes a god man

  • when compassion leaves

  • where have all the disciples gone

  • where to start

  • who made god

  • why hinduism is terrorism

  • why i dont speak in tongues part ii

  • why muslims are losing ground

  • why the extremes

  • winners and losers

  • witchcraft christianity

  • womens place in islam

  • works works or works

  • your endless journey to more abundant life

  • zimbabwe land of tears

  • zombies of the christian reich