Search
Related Links

 

 

Informative Articles

Balanced Scorecard, Strategic Planning
The Balanced Scorecard deals with effective business performance measurement and implementing strategic planning. Balanced Scorecard approach is a well documented management approach developed by a group of people from Fortune 500...
Choking on ITIL? - A Menu for Success
Choking on ITIL? A Menu for Success ... Food for thought "Frankly, I'm desperate - I'm choking" is a phrase I've become familiar with over the years. Faced with a daily diet of conflicting business priorities, resistant staff and increasing...
Preparing to be an Entrepreneur
I believe the free market economy and the wealth of a community is built on the back of the entrepreneur Taking the entrepreneurial business path can be exciting, exhilarating, and an emotional roller coaster of ups and downs. There are a number of...
Professionalizing The Family Business
Professionalizing the Family Business Family business expert discusses the difficult and emotionally destructive problems confronted In the 30 years I have been working as a family business consultant, the most difficult and emotionally...
The Project Management Mindset
Project management as a science and art is undergoing key transformations as a result of countless stories of failed projects, cost overruns, and canceling that project that took 2 years of your employee's lives. Needless to say, these scenarios...
 
Marketing Planning and Control Systems: From Agency Style to Nerve Center

Introduction

PMI Corp is a century-old firm that pioneered the use of direct mail sales for life and health insurance. Over the past century, PMI Corp has evolved from a firm that focuses solely on direct mail into a multi-channel firm, selling insurance through agents, brokers and (still) through direct mail. Growing in tandem with PMI Corp's sales force is the insurance regulatory environment, which has also become increasingly complex.

To respond to the complex regulatory environment--and to support the firm's internal sales processes--PMI Corp decided to refine the process by which it generates, distributes, and manages sales opportunities (i.e. leads). PMI Corp purchased and implemented a lead management system to ensure that qualified and unqualified leads had all necessary data for delivery to a specific agent. Additionally, the lead management system contained rules to ensure that leads could be distributed effectively, with minimal human intervention. Data pertaining to managing the lead (when the person was contacted, when the lead was closed, whether it resulted in a sold policy, etc.) was stored in a Decision Support System ("DSS") in the lead management system for analysis. PMI Corp used the lead management system as a framework for planning (by using the data in the DSS) and control (routing rules ensured compliance with government regulations and internal policies).

By implementing a lead management system, PMI Corp took its first significant step from management by agency to management by nerve theory. Traditionally, PMI Corp relied on a hierarchical structure characterized by the tight control of information and authority. With the adoption of a system that facilitates access to information, PMI Corp (unconsciously) approached a nerve center approach to management. The use of reporting analysts to develop ad hoc reports, as well as the focus on information to drive decisions at the marketing manager level, indicates this move.

About the Firm's Planning and Control Systems

Controls PMI Corp's control requirements were driven by regulatory obligations and internal business policies (which had evolved to the point that they were perceived as law). While the regulatory and internal requirements never resulted in conflict, the need to satisfy both led to an environment characterized by detailed, complicated controls, and planning that addressed the needs of a balkanized organization with divisional attitudes of blatant self-interest. Consequently, planning had to address the performance of each business unit in considering the future allocation of marketing dollars, while accounting for markets traditionally "owned" by each division.

PMI Corp's lead management system absolutely needed to have lead routing rules that recognized the regulatory obligations imposed on the insurance industry. Thus, the lead management system needed to facilitate control of the following elements: * State Authorization: leads from states in which PMI Corp was not licensed to sell insurance could not be distributed to agents * Agent Licensing: agents could not receive leads for products that they were not licensed to sell * Do Not Solicit: leads regarding prisoners, the deceased, and people asked not to be called (unless they initiated this request for service) could not be distributed to agents, and a list of these people had to be maintained Thus, clear regulatory requirements led to specific controls that had to be enacted. PMI Corp had an obligation to its agents to follow these rules as well. Giving agents these leads would erode the relationship between the sales force and the home office.

PMI Corp's sales channels--quite territorial in nature--developed a series of internal policies over time (resulting from ongoing "negotiations" ). In distributing leads to the different sales channels, PMI Corp had to develop controls in the lead routing rules to ensure that leads were distributed to the appropriate channels. PMI Corp's internally-driven controls included: * Payment Means Ownership: the division that paid for the marketing campaign is entitled to all leads that come from that campaign * Except When Trumped: a lead from a customer that belongs to a vested agent overrides the notion of payment (described above) * Division Managers Have Autonomy: a lead is distributed to a division manager (who runs a field office), and the division manager distributes the leads to his agents at his discretion. The lead routing logic had to ensure that these internal rules were enforced. In some cases, these rules came from traditions and victory in political battle. In other cases (such as the vested agents rule above), the rules resulted from contractual obligations between the firm and the sales force.

Planning The lead routing logic directly addressed the role of controls in the organization. The data generated by the interaction of users with the lead management system contributed to the planning component of PMI Corp's PCS. User interaction with the lead management system yielded the following information: * Field Office Performance: sales success by field office (sales rate, sales by product, average time to close, sales by campaign) * Agent Performance: sales success by agent (sales rate, average time to close, preferred products) * Channel Performance: lead closure rates by sales channel (direct marketing, agency, brokerage) * Product Performance: sales by product across the firm * Campaign Performance: the effectiveness of different marketing campaigns Using this information, the division managers and home office (especially the marketing department) were able to understand how well PMI Corp was doing in the market, and what changes should be made in the future in order to compete more effectively.

PMI Corp mined this data using a series of planned and ad hoc reports, generated by reporting analysts who focused specifically on these tasks. In addition to analyzing performance, PMI Corp studied agent and field office activity, in order to identify ways to streamline the ways that agents conducted their business. The notion of ad hoc reporting signaled the move to a "nerve center" approach to managing the sales force. Information became primary for decision making, which helped reduce the balkanization across the firm.

The Technology Solution

In order to manage this increasingly complex planning and controls environment, PMI Corp recognized the need for technology to play a central role in managing the distribution and tracking of leads. Traditionally, these controls had been delegated to the office administrators in each of the field offices. Lower


level, non-sales employees assumed the responsibility for ensuring that leads were distributed within each office in accordance with the internal and regulatory controls in place. Lead distribution to channels and offices occurred at the home office, using simplistic and inaccurate software tools. Leads were frequently lost or inappropriately distributed. PMI Corp realized that they could no longer rely on the "human touch" to enable proper and effective lead distribution.

Controls The controls framework in the lead management system existed as lead routing logic in the lead management system. Essentially, the routing logic provided rules for delivering leads to the different users' "inboxes". There were two types of rules: routing and suggested assignment. Rigid controls were met using the routing rules. These rules ensured that a new lead, as it entered the system, was routed directly to an agent. Suggested assignment rules delivered the leads to a field office, and the division manager could see to whom the lead should be delivered, but could disregard the recommendation if he chose.

Lead routing logic provided controls at all levels of the organization. At the home office (where leads entered the system), routing logic addressed the specific sales channel to which a lead should be sent. Typically, routing at this level was defined by the division that paid for the lead. Additionally, filtering at the home office level facilitated removing leads for those who could not be serviced (such as the deceased), leads from states in which PMI Corp was not licensed, and leads for inactive products.

At the channel level, the lead management system had controls specific to each channel. The agency channels routing logic was most rigidly defined, because there were more regulatory and internal policy controls in the agency channel than in direct marketing and brokerage. Within agency, leads were routed to field offices based on state, and by zip code when a state had multiple offices. When a lead arrived at an office, an agent-specific assignment was recommended based on controls defined at the field office level. Consequently, there were hard and soft controls at both levels within agency. Agency executives (at the home office) determined how leads would be distributed to home offices, agency division managers (at the field offices) would decide how leads were distributed to specific agents.

Planning The lead management system contributed to simpler management of a complex planning and budgeting process. PMI Corp's marketing budgeting process occurs over a six-month period. Discussions begin in June, and a preliminary budget is created by September, which is reviewed by October and finalized by year-end. The planning and budgeting process accomplishes: Determining which major marketing campaigns to run Identifying the types of media to use in these marketing campaigns Assigning budgets to each campaign Allocating campaigns to sales channels Setting goals and measurement techniques for success PMI Corp's planning process was quite detailed, and provided a detailed blueprint for marketing throughout the year.

Throughout the year, the marketing plan is adjusted as necessary, based on feedback from the marketplace. Reporting analysts used a variety of data interpretation techniques to determine the changes necessary. Analysts typically developed ad hoc reports to provide detailed information regarding specific marketplace feedback. This data was used to validate hunches, confirm changes of direction, and determine the possible outcomes of different changes. Planning, in this case, changed from overall strategic planning to tactical planning--planning to address specific needs as they arise.

Organizational Change The drastic change in PMI Corp's approach to lead management triggered the need for organizational change. To ensure that the various lead management system controls were working effectively, and to support the management process, PMI Corp decided to create a lead management team in the marketing department. The role of the lead management team was to ensure that the rules in the system continued to meet the organization's evolving needs, as well as to find ways to continue to streamline the lead management process. The lead management team also addressed strategic and tactical reporting requirements, and developed solutions to ensure that the requisite data was fed to the DSS to be used in reporting tasks.

The lead management team became the nerve center of the lead management environment across the entire firm. They gathered, managed, and interpreted lead data from all sales channels, and provided guidance to marketing and sales channel executives based on their interpretations of the data. This team's mission was to acquire and store information, and recall that information to solve problems and capitalize on opportunities when the needs arise. This maps perfectly to Macintosh's characterization of nerve center theory, which has the manager constantly learning from a variety of sources (many anecdotal), and recalling that information when something in the business environment triggers a recollection.

Conclusion: Technology Takes PMI Corp from Agency to Nerve Center

PMI Corp will always retain characteristics of a traditional agency organization. While most "agency" firms operate via implicit contracts between individuals (owners and management, management and employees), PMI Corp relies in some cases on explicit, well-defined contracts. This clearly "agency" characteristic does not preclude the transition of PMI Corp to a nerve center organization. In fact, nerve center management enables PMI Corp to uphold its contracts with agents and brokers more effectively. The implementation of the lead management solution has enabled PMI Corp to gather and interpret more information, for use in granular analysis as well as strategy definition. Using this information, the marketing department becomes a repository of information on how PMI Corp has worked with each of its customers. Every element of the sales cycle for every lead is captured in this system, and these granular details can be gathered into general information on campaign, product, and channel performance. With the marketing department as a clearinghouse for information, PMI Corp begins the move from an organization built on structure to an organization built on information and decision enablement.

About the author:

j-knowledge, LLC creates original web and print copy for high-performing businesses around the world. For more information, please contact Tom Johansmeyer at 617.669.0895.

 

Strategic Planning (in nonprofit or for-profit organizations)
Adapted from the Field Guide to Nonprofit Strategic Planning and Facilitation. ... First, a Point About For-Profit and Nonprofit Strategic Planning ...
www.managementhelp.org
 
Basic Description of Strategic Planning (including key terms to know)
Adapted from the Field Guide to Nonprofit Strategic Planning and Facilitation. ... Strategic planning often includes use of several key terms. ...
www.managementhelp.org
 
Strategic Planning, Strategic Plan, Business Strategy, Strategic ...
Strategic planning advice with free strategic planner & sample strategic plan covering mission statement, SWOT analysis with business plan software for cash ...
www.planware.org
 
Strategic Planning
FAQs regarding strategic planning - geared primarily toward non-profit organizations but with enough detail and general information to provide useful ...
www.allianceonline.org
 
Frequently Asked Questions
Strategic Planning · Fundraising · Financial Management · Risk Management · Credit Card Acceptance. The FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions) listed on this ...
www.allianceonline.org
 
Strategic planning - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Strategic planning involves defining objectives and developing ... Strategic planning uses "the big picture" to pursue large scale, long term objectives. ...
en.wikipedia.org
 
08/26/96 STRATEGIC PLANNING
You guessed it: strategic planning. Suddenly, the idea of rising above the ... But if strategic planning is back with a vengeance, it's also back with a ...
www.businessweek.com
 
Dr. Strategy - Dr. Pete Johnson, Keynote Speaker, Marketing ...
StrategicPlanning.com “Turning Change Into A Competitive Advantage”. Dr. Pete's Preview Video Click Here. Take-Away Value Sample Program Handouts ...
strategicplanning.com
 
Strategic Planning Society: Strategy Development and Implementation
Strategic Planning Society: Strategy Development and Implementation.
www.sps.org.uk
 
Guide 7
Strategic Planning in Smaller Nonprofit Organizations ... In short, as a result of a strategic planning process, an organization will have a clearer idea of ...
www.wmich.edu
 
STRATEGIC PLANNING MANUAL
File Format: PDF/Adobe Acrobat - View as HTML
Your browser may not have a PDF reader available. Google recommends visiting our text version of this document.
 
BPubs.com: Strategic Planning & Business Planning Articles
Business Publications related to Corporate Strategic Planning.
www.bpubs.com
 
Strategic Planning Tools
Strategic Planning is a method for positioning an organization to take ... A strategic planning process incorporates an in-depth planning model that takes ...
www.nsba.org
 
Center for Simplified Strategic Planning, Inc.
The Center for Simplified Strategic Planning offers training, seminars, consulting, speakers, workshops, a book and a newsletter on strategic management for ...
www.cssp.com
 
LEADERSHIP: Strategic Planning and Strategic Management
Introduction: Is strategic planning really worth it? ... The purpose of strategic planning is to encourage thinking about your organization's "big ...
vskn.ca
 
The CEO Refresher Archives - Strategic Planning
When done right, the integrated strategic planning process can take a ... Strategic Planning and Project Management: The Key to Successful Implementation ...
www.refresher.com
 
HEFCE : Publications : 2000 : 00/24 - Strategic planning in higher ...
This guide reviews good practice in strategic planning in higher education (HE). It originated in a consultation exercise which we held in 1998 to review ...
www.hefce.ac.uk
 
The Association for Strategic Planning
The Association for Strategic Planning (ASP), is a non-profit professional society whose mission is to enable people and organizations to succeed through ...
www.strategyplus.org
 
Amazon.com: Strategic Planning for Nonprofit Organizations: A ...
Amazon.com: Strategic Planning for Nonprofit Organizations: A Practical Guide and Workbook: Books: Michael Allison,Jude Kaye by Michael Allison,Jude Kaye.
www.amazon.com
 
Amazon.com: Simplified Strategic Planning: A No-Nonsense Guide for ...
Amazon.com: Simplified Strategic Planning: A No-Nonsense Guide for Busy People Who Want Results Fast!: Books: Robert W. Bradford,Robert W. Bradford,J. Peter ...
www.amazon.com
 
 

 
Content Menu

  • 10 lessons for every shoestring entrepreneur

  • 10 reasons why time and attendance systems are not just substitutes for clock cards

  • 10 tips for managing your time

  • 10 ways to help you plan your home office for productivity and comfort

  • 2005 economic update industry specific 2005 total compensation budget predictions

  • 5 steps to powerful negotiating feature article

  • 5 warning signals your business might have a cash flow problem

  • 6 steps to laying out your competitive strategy

  • 7 essential elements of leading change

  • 8 reasons the holidays are a great time to build your business

  • achieving competitive advantage through collaboration with key customers and suppliers

  • affluent market may disappoint retailers by spending less for december holiday gifts

  • affluent men spend twice as much on holiday gifts for their spouse as women do

  • affluent name recipients of december holiday gifts in new survey

  • affluent turn cautious in outlook for personal spending and the economy

  • attract and retain top talent

  • a cyber staffing solution for small businesses

  • a guide to performance management

  • a real business coach

  • a renewed view of the modern business culture

  • a strategy for success

  • balanced scorecard strategic planning

  • barriers to effective planning

  • being a home based business owner whats not to love

  • being stressed out may not be all that bad

  • best practice benchmarking the path to excellence

  • blueprint for change

  • book summary mind your own business

  • bottleneck oriented business management

  • bridge loans everything you wanted to know

  • building win win alliances

  • build winning alliances

  • business 101 passion before planning

  • business growth through strategic merger and acquisition

  • business intelligence advancements transform corporate decision making

  • business or leisure make sure you get the best stay

  • business planning 101

  • business planning myopia

  • business plans what consultants dont tell you

  • business plan basics

  • business process automation bpa

  • buying a business advice for the first time buyer investor

  • buy now retire later an investment in your dreams

  • cash flow profits and the cash conversion cycle

  • change management can lead to rigidity and resistance to change

  • change may be your ace in the hole

  • chasm of change restructuring the goliath of change

  • choking on itil a menu for success

  • client service as a competitive advantage

  • coaching an adapting tool for attaining fulfillment in the global economy

  • coaching for lawyers 10 ways a lawyer can benefit from working with a professional coach

  • collaboration not competition

  • common sources of financing for small business

  • comparing corporate and personal goal attainment programs that have developed over thousands of years with modern day programs

  • compensation committee 101 what does it do

  • competitive marketing analysis

  • creating a business strategy

  • creating a vision

  • cultivating your pathway to success dont leave your companys future to chance

  • dealing with anger

  • developing your mission

  • develop a successful business foundation second to none

  • discover the coach within you

  • does your culture support or sabotage your strategy

  • dont allow yourself to get burned

  • embrace diversity to build effective teams

  • entrepreneur to employer considerations

  • famous business strategies

  • fatal mistakes to avoid when writing a business plan

  • finding and keeping good people

  • five strategies to strengthen your companys financial management

  • focus on results not money

  • four reasons why small businesses succeed or fail

  • franchises exit strategies

  • franchises whats the exit strategy

  • generating publicity will the media be interested in my product business

  • getting and keeping good people

  • getting together the importance of business relationships

  • have you ever thought of joining or forming a consortium

  • help wanted new business leadership required to jumpstart the american economy

  • home business grants

  • how effective is your leadership style

  • how joint ventures can catapult you to success

  • how not to let powerpoint kill your presentation

  • how to accelerate the return on investment roi of your senior talent

  • how to create a great mentoring relationship

  • how to develop a successful board of advisors and why you should

  • how to develop multiple streams of 100 000 home business income

  • how to easily accelerate your profits

  • how to use graphs and charts in your business plan

  • hr off shoring outsourcing a buyers market

  • human resource communication pays off

  • ideas are free a book summary

  • identifying candidates for leadership

  • if one does not do any planning one is planning to fail

  • improve profitable roe with retention

  • index

  • investing in the czech republic outside of prague part 1 brno property

  • investments short term or long term

  • isg expands to include denovo bank consulting

  • its spring time for a compensation program tune up

  • its time to get all strategic small business marketing stategy

  • i wanna hold your hand first time homebuyers

  • i want to get a mortgage fast online

  • job search lessons from the super bowl

  • job talk the heart of productivity

  • leadership and customer service is there a link

  • leadership development turn on your employees

  • leading with power and authority energize others with deep green leadership

  • learn to manage your projects with project management training software

  • living life in a time starved world

  • lone wolf lead wolf

  • make your mark how to attract clients and grow your business

  • making the most of your year

  • making your item get the best bid on e bay

  • management span of control and the power of models

  • managers have you been shortchanged

  • managers lets call a spade a spade

  • managers should your pr budget stress tactics or strategy

  • managers you know your job but what about public relations

  • managing the human resource project

  • managing transformational change within the public sector

  • managing with vision

  • marketing planning and control systems from agency style to nerve center

  • maybe you should worry about your pr

  • meetings bloody meetings

  • merger and acquisition an engine for corporate growth

  • millionaires name top choices for holiday gift wish list

  • mission and vision statements foundational to successful change

  • new years resolutions for your business

  • non profits need new strategies to weather budget crisis

  • not another ice breaker team building with a purpose

  • oe consultants is there a future for them

  • operational excellence for wholesale distributors

  • performance measures a key to organizational success

  • planning to make a decision

  • plan for business success 6 reasons to succession plan

  • practice on purpose working on your business

  • pragmatic consulting from the clients perspective

  • preparing to be an entrepreneur

  • printing offline

  • professionalizing the family business

  • professional intervention in the family business

  • profit the goal and more than margins

  • pr lets dump the smoke and mirrors

  • public relations a natural phenomenon

  • public relations converting the non believers

  • public relations defining your organization from the inside out

  • public relations power tool for the 21st century

  • quality consulting major consumer products company

  • quick books and finances

  • ready fire aim

  • ready setwait

  • renovations and upgrades bring it to the bank part 2

  • resolve to focus on results in 2006 website results that is

  • rotator

  • rules to setting business goals and objectives why and how to be smart

  • secrets to successful publishing

  • selling your business for the best price

  • selling your technology company why earnouts make sense today

  • sell a business 10 steps to maximize selling price

  • setting goals and implementing change

  • setting you sails the mission statement

  • should you write your own business plan

  • six disciplines for excellence

  • small business planning three myths

  • small business q a swot analysis is no magic 8 ball

  • small business q a the business autopsy a fact of life

  • so you dont have a business plan why not

  • starting a small business is just like running the peachtree only tougher

  • starting your business avoiding the me incorporated syndrome

  • start thinking strategically about your business

  • strategic clarity for communication management

  • strategic internet marketing 5 basic keys to online business success

  • strategic organizational learning

  • strategic planning and consulting

  • strategic planning basics

  • strategic planning for salespeople

  • strategic planning steps for optimum business management

  • strategies to time management

  • succeeding as a seller on e bay

  • succession planning problems getting started

  • succession three tips to ease the transition

  • succss tip business plannning 101

  • survival without computers

  • surviving survival

  • swot analysis is no magic 8 ball

  • swot analysis strengths weaknesses opportunities and threats

  • tactical hints for succession planning

  • tales from the corporate frontlines try try again

  • temporary staffing agency how to start

  • ten tips for creating a terrific employee appraisal system

  • ten ways to sharpen your business edge

  • the 7 traits of an exceptional and successful entrepreneur

  • the 7 traits of an exceptional successful entrepreneur

  • the art of succession planning

  • the business autopsy a fact of life

  • the case of the vanishing technology

  • the challenges of human resource management

  • the collapse of enron

  • the crisis of modernity

  • the dos and donts of creating business partnerships

  • the five biggest mistakes an hr professional can make from the clients perspective

  • the inferno of the finance director

  • the magic and mystery of teams

  • the project management mindset

  • the role of the business model and strategy for business

  • the ten pillars of leadership and business development

  • the three factors of leadership motivation

  • thoughtleading the art of separating yourself from the pack

  • three planning myths

  • three steps to give your strategic plan traction

  • time management is a work of art

  • tips to maximize the sale of your business

  • top tips for effective time management

  • to all managers how does add affect your workplace

  • trade show exhibit booth 7 tips to improve yours

  • trade show victory

  • trend setting how office art improves productivity

  • understanding financial statements when approaching lenders

  • useful tips for evaluating your meeting venue options

  • what are we teaching pr students

  • what could macedonia learn from a tiger the asian tigers and the phenomenon of uninterrupted economic growth

  • what if peter drucker were your ceo

  • what is a trainer what is a facilitator

  • what is google adsense

  • what to consider before approaching lenders

  • what your home based business plan can do for you

  • what you must do for one whole day every week for your business

  • when and where the affluent shop for december holiday gifts

  • when tactics are not enough

  • who do you talk to

  • why bother with customer centricity

  • why have a mortgage coach

  • why just the right ppc campaign management brings in lots and lots of cash

  • writing a business plan

  • your 7 minute mba

  • your business or your life why not both

  • your online fortune is just a click away