Search
Related Links

 

 

Informative Articles

Cambodian Song Is Contributing to Discrimination
It is exactly our desires to entertain and such the right is stipulated in many internal and international legal instruments. To me, entertainment is not just entertainment, but it does enrich our lives, physically and psychologically....

Critical Thinking To Go: Dodging The Pepperoni Pizza Fallacy
This brief article on clear thinking borrows an illustration from the fast food industry to make a spicey point about proper and improper reasoning. It tackles an error common to popular musings and media spin, but which has yet to make its way...

Make your Speech a Success…
In some colleges and universities after submitting your term papers you have to present them orally.  You are expected to make public speeches and to capture the attention of your exacting professors. How to avoid such comment from their...

The World of Internet
Internet.... It entered our lives not so long ago, but made a revolutionary change in the lives of all the mankind. Internet brought a new quality of communication, information, services, etc into the world. It helps to sell and buy, communicate...

The World of Internet
We can’t ignore the influence of the internet on our lives. Some say it is negative, the others state it is positive. Internet….  It entered our lives not so long ago, but made a revolutionary change in the lives of all the...

 
Albert Einstein, the dishonest Newton ?!

Copyright 2011 Vincent Wilmot

Newton's black-box physics.

From laws of force and motion in mechanics, Isaac Newton developed laws of orbital motion around 'centres of force' and saw gravity as governing the motions of the celestial bodies as well as apples falling from trees. But despite using the 'force' terminology perhaps more readily associated with mechanics, Newton concluded that gravity might be due to unseen signals acting across empty space in line with William Gilbert's physics theory, or might be caused by the impact force of unseen ether matter in line with Rene Descartes physics. But Newton saw his laws of science as correctly predicting natural events without the need to know why things happened, in the manner of 'black box' behaviour laws that related only inputs or stimuli to outputs or responses. Newton considered hypotheses regarding unseens like 'gravity signals crossing space' or 'ether matter filling space' as matters of philosophy or logic and not science, but as not easily disproven by science. Newton's physics was about what the universe did, but explicitly excluded explanations of why.

Up to Albert Einstein's time, physicists and astronomers had been almost all agreed that the physical universe followed basically simple laws of behaviour, and that their observations and experiments showed that. But technology and experiments became more sophisticated and seemed to be showing that the physical universe followed more complex laws of behaviour, perhaps even defying logic, and so Einstein developed his physics theory.

Einstein's space-time physics.

Einstein's view of gravity involved a substantially different kind of Descartes 'ether matter' filling space. Einstein concluded that there existed a space-time continuum whose local metrical qualities differ in the environment of different points of space-time, being partly conditioned by the matter existing outside of the territory under consideration. This space-time variability of the reciprocal relations of the standards of space and time, required that "empty space'' in its physical relation be neither homogeneous nor isotropic and its state be described by ten functions (of the gravitation potentials g) - space not being physically empty. This 'ether' of Einstein's general theory of relativity is a medium which is itself devoid of all mechanical and kinematical qualities, but somehow helps to determine mechanical (and electromagnetic) events.

What is fundamentally new in the ether of Einstein's general theory of relativity as opposed to the ethers of Descartes or Lorentz consists in its state at every place being determined by connections with the matter and the state of the ether in neighbouring places which are amenable to law in the form of differential


equations. And in Einstein's space-time continuum, time itself becomes variable. There hence can be no space nor any part of space without gravitational potentials; for these confer upon space-time its metrical qualities, without which a space-time continuum cannot be imagined at all.

Einstein being dishonest to himself ?

In Einstein's general relativity physics bodies impose curves on his time-space-gravity continuum, and the continuum imposes motion on bodies. Although push-physics analogies such as rubber-sheets are often used to 'explain' this, the theory does not involve any push-physics mechanism and indeed does not specify any clear mechanism for this. Gravitational forces of any kind are completely abolished as controlling the motion of planets or other bodies, and somehow space-curves do this - logically by pushings yet seemingly without having any push properties since the continuum is non-material ?

Einstein concluded that "the ether of the general theory of relativity is a medium which is itself devoid of all mechanical and kinematical qualities, but helps to determine mechanical (and electromagnetic) events." But if this leaves the improved maths of Einstein's theory with no realistic explanation of why the universe works as it does, then his theory must be basically taken (as Newton intended his theory to be taken) as a blackbox theory of what happens with the real why explanation an unknown.

Yet Einstein did repeatedly allow of 'rubber-sheets' type anologies for his theory's supposed why explanations - when it actually has no why explanation. He was perhaps not being intentionally dishonest to the world, but almost certainy was being dishonest with himself in not fully facing his theory's chief weakness - its being basically an improved Newton black-box physics and not more than that ?

The maths of Einstein's theory certainly seems to predict better than the maths of Newton's theory in some areas, but that in itself is perhaps no proof of Einstein's theory of what the universe is and does - and still less of any explanation of why it works ? Albert Einstein's theory of relativity even he considered to be at least incomplete, and perhaps also giving no real explanation, and now it perhaps is chiefly supported by cosmologists and astronomers. But despite modern quantum physics development like string, loop and other quantal theories that seem supported mostly by 'particle physicists' using field and particle-wave duality ideas, it can perhaps be said that nobody has yet successfully published any physics theory better than Einstein's still limited theory ?

About the author:

Vincent Wilmot currently lives in Grimsby UK and has several very interesting websites including ; http://www.new-science-theory.com

 

philosophy: the best cosmetic is great-looking skin
the best skin of your life is at your fingertips. owner and ceo of philosophy, cristina carlino, is the creator, founder and former ceo of BioMedic, ...
www.philosophy.com
 
The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Non-profit organization that collects and makes available original articles about philosophy topics. University of Tennessee at Martin.
www.iep.utm.edu
 
Philosophy - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
The entrance page to all articles in the philosophy section of the free encyclopedia.
en.wikipedia.org
 
Philosophy Pages
Aids to the study of philosophy, including study guide, dictionary, timeline, discussion of major philosophers, and links to e-texts.
www.philosophypages.com
 
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Online encyclopedia of philosophy created and maintained by Stanford University.
plato.stanford.edu
 
Table of Contents
Arabic and Islamic Philosophy, historical and methodological topics in ... Beattie, James — see Scottish Philosophy: in the 18th Century; Beauvoir, ...
plato.stanford.edu
 
Philosophy Collection
Links to canonical philosophic texts available for viewing.
philosophy.eserver.org
 
Guide to Philosophy on the Internet (Suber)
A regularly updated collection of online philosophy resources by Peter Suber of Earlham College.
www.earlham.edu
 
Humanities > Philosophy in the Yahoo! Directory
Browse resources about philosophers and philosophy, including schools of thought, study guides, university departments, and conferences.
dir.yahoo.com
 
Bristol University - Department of Philosophy - Home
With 13 permanent members of staff, we are larger than many philosophy departments in the UK. Our interests cover a wide range of topics within the Analytic ...
www.bris.ac.uk
 
Google Corporate Information: Our Philosophy
Our Philosophy. Never settle for the best "The perfect search engine," says Google co-founder Larry Page, "would understand exactly what you mean and give ...
www.google.com
 
Philosophy of the GNU Project - GNU Project - Free Software ...
This directory describes the philosophy of the Free Software Movement, which is the motivation for our development of the free software operating system GNU ...
www.gnu.org
 
Intute: Arts and Humanities - Philosophy
Search or browse the database of Philosophy resources which have been selected, evaluated and described by subject specialists. ...
www.intute.ac.uk
 
EpistemeLinks: For Philosophy Resources on the Internet
EpistemeLinks is a comprehensive resource for philosophy on the Internet, providing thousands of links categorized by philosopher, topic, and resource type.
www.epistemelinks.com
 
Cambridge Journals Online - Display Journal
Philosophy is the journal of the Royal Institute of Philosophy, which was founded in 1925 to build bridges between specialist philosophers and a wider ...
journals.cambridge.org
 
MIT philosophy home page
Department of Linguistics and Philosophy - Cambridge, Massachusetts - BA, PhD.
web.mit.edu
 
The Philosophers' Magazine Online
Philosophy articles, bookstore, events, and discussion board.
www.philosophersnet.com
 
VoS - Voice of the Shuttle
The Philosophy of Complexity Per Se with Application to Some Examples in Evolution" ... Philosophy is Everybody's Business: Great Ideas from the Great Books ...
vos.ucsb.edu
 
Philosophy Now
Bi-monthly, non-academic publication with news, articles, and columns aimed at those with an interest in philosophy. Site features select full-text articles ...
www.philosophynow.org
 
Philosophy around the Web
Guide and a gateway to philosophy resources on the Internet, by Dr Peter J. King, University of Oxford.
users.ox.ac.uk