Search
Related Links

 

 

Informative Articles

Basic Home Loan Terms Explained
The wonderful world of home buying can sometimes overwhelm the first time homebuyer. They are inundated with information riddled with terms of art. ARMS, points, interest rates, good faith estimates, pay-downs, lock-in dates, so on and so forth. ...

Eight Ways to Consolidate Debt
Next to winning the lottery, a debt consolidation loan is a debtor’s dream. With one monthly payment and a fixed monthly payment schedule, you can actually see an end to those monthly payments. In reality, consolidating bills isn’t always...

Go Multinational
Go Multinational By William Cate If you are marketing your quality product or service in any country, you should be selling it in every country. Going Multinational is more than increasing your access to customers. It's a formula for increased...

THE “SEVEN Cs”: PARTNERSHIP DANGER SIGNS - The 5th C: Control Issues
A series of articles exploring the seven critical areas that can indicate a partnership is in trouble. The 5th C: Control Issues When control is in the picture it is a lose/lose proposition. First, it is an illusion that anyone can...

What’s It Worth?
Sound financial business planning means taking ongoing assessment steps looking at the business from multiple perspectives including capitalization, expansion, menu concepts, cash flow and even an exit strategy. Whether you are a chef dreaming...

 
SELLING YOUR TECHNOLOGY COMPANY - WHY EARNOUTS MAKE SENSE TODAY

The purpose of this article is to present earnouts to sellers of technology companies as a method to maximize their transaction proceeds. Sellers have historically viewed earnouts with suspicion as a way for buyers to get control of their companies cheaply. Earnouts are a variable pricing mechanism designed to tie final sale price to future performance of the acquired entity and are tied to measurable economic milestones such as revenues, gross profit, net income and EBITDA. An intelligently structured earnout not only can facilitate the closing of a deal, but can be a win for both buyer and seller. Below are ten reasons earnouts should be considered as part of your selling transaction structure.

1.Buyers acquisition multiples are at pre 1992 levels. Strategic corporate buyers, private equity groups, and venture capital firms got burned on valuations. Between 1995 and 2001 the premiums paid by corporate buyers in 61% of transactions were greater than the economic gains. In other words, the buyer suffered from dilution. During 2002 multiples paid by financial buyers were almost equal to strategic buyers multiples. This is not a favorable pricing environment for tech companies looking for strategic pricing.

2.Based on the bubble, there is a great deal of investor skepticism. They no longer take for granted integration synergies and are weary about cultural clashes, unexpected costs, logistical problems and when their investment becomes accretive. If the seller is willing to take on some of that risk in the form of an earnout based on integrated performance, he will be offered a more attractive package (only if realistic targets are set and met).

3.Many tech companies are struggling and valuing them based on income will produce some pretty unspectacular results. A buyer will be far more willing to look at an acquisition candidate using strategic multiples if the seller is willing to take on a portion of the post closing performance risk. The key stakeholders of the seller have an incentive to stay on to make their earnout come to fruition, a situation all buyers desire.

4.An old business professor once asked, “What would you rather have, all of a grape or part of a watermelon?” The spirit of the entrepreneur causes many tech company owners to go it alone. The odds are against them achieving critical mass with current resources. They could grow organically and become a grape or they could integrate with a strategic acquirer and achieve their current distribution times 100 or 1000. Six % of this new revenue stream will far surpass 100% of the old one.

5.How many of you have heard of the thrill of victory and the agony of defeat of stock purchases at dizzying multiples? It went something like this – Public Company A with a stock price of $50 per share buys Private Company B for a 15 x EBITDA multiple in an all stock deal with a one-year restriction on sale of the stock. Lets say that the resultant sales proceeds were 160,000 shares totaling $8 million in value. Company A’s stock goes on a steady decline and by the time you can sell, the price is $2.50. Now the effective sale price of your company becomes $400,000. Your 15 x EBITDA multiple evaporated to a multiple of less than one. Compare that result to $5 million cash at close and an earnout that totals $5 million over the next 3 years if revenue targets for your division are met. Your minimum guaranteed multiple is 9.38 x with an upside of 18.75x.

6.Strategic corporate buyers are reluctant to use their devalued stock as the currency of choice for acquisitions. Their preferred currency is cash. By agreeing to an earnout, you give the buyer’s cash more velocity (ability to make more acquisitions with their cash) and therefore become a more attractive candidate with the ability to ask for greater compensation in the future.

7.The market is starting to turn positive which reawakens sellers’ dreams of bubble type multiples. The buyers are looking back to the historical norm or pre-bubble pricing. The seller believes that this market deserves a premium and the buyers have raised their standards thus hindering negotiations. An earnout is a way to break this impasse. The seller moves the total selling price up. The buyer stays within their guidelines while potentially paying for the earnout premium with


dollars that are the result of additional earnings from the new acquisition.

8.The improving market provides both the seller and the buyer growth leverage. When negotiating the earnout component, buyers will be very generous in future compensation if the acquired company exceeds their projections. Projections that look very aggressive for the seller with their pre-merger resources, suddenly become quite attainable as part of a new company entering a period of growth. An example might look like this: Oracle acquires a small software Company B that has developed Oracle conversion and integration software tools. Last year Company B had sales of $8 million and EBITDA of $1 million. Company B had grown by 20% per year. The purchase transaction was structured to provide Company B $8 million of Oracle stock and $2 million cash at close plus an earnout that would pay Company B a % of $1 million a year for the next 3 years based on their achieving a 30% compound growth rate in sales. If Company B hit sales of $10.4, $13.52, and $17.58 million respectively for the next 3 years, they would collect another $3 million in transaction value. The seller now expands his client base from 200 to 100,000 installed accounts and his sales force from 4 to 5,000. Those targets should be very easy to hit. If these targets are met, the buyer easily finances the earnout with extra profit.

9.The window of opportunity in the technology area opens and closes very quickly. An earnout structure can allow both the buyer and seller to benefit. If the smaller company has developed a winning technology, they usually have a short period of time to establish a lead in the market. If they are addressing a compelling technology gap, the odds are that companies both large and small are developing their own solution simultaneously. The seller wants to develop the potential of the product and achieve sales numbers to drive up the company’s selling price. They do not have the distribution channels, the resources, or time to compete with a larger company with a similar solution looking to establish the industry standard. A larger acquiring company recognizes this first mover advantage and is willing to pay a buy versus build premium to reduce their time to market. The seller wants a large premium while the buyer is not willing to pay full value for projections with stock and cash at close. The solution: an earnout for the seller that handsomely rewards him for meeting those projections. He gets the resources and distribution capability of the buyer so the product can reach standard setting critical mass before another large company can knock it off. The buyer gets to market quicker and achieves first mover advantage while incurring only a portion of the risk of new product development and introduction.

10.You never can forget about taxes. Earnouts provide a vehicle to defer and reduce the seller’s tax liability. Be sure to discuss your potential deal structure and tax consequences with your advisors before final negotiations begin. A properly structured earnout could save you significant tax dollars.

Smaller technology companies have many characteristics that make them good candidates for earnouts in sale transactions: 1. High growth rates, 2. Earnings not supportive of maximum valuations, 3. Limited window of opportunity to achieve meaningful market penetration, 4. Buyers less willing to pay for future potential entirely at the sale closing and 5. A valuation expectation far greater than those supported by the buyers. It really comes down to how confident the seller is in the performance of his company in the post sale environment. If the earnout targets are reasonably attainable and the earnout compensates him for the at risk portion of transaction value, a seller can significantly improve the likelihood of a sale closing and the transaction value.

About the Author

Dave Kauppi is a Merger and Acquisition Advisor with Mid Market Capital, Inc. MMC is a business broker firm specializing in middle market corporate clients. We provide M&A and divestiture, succession planning, valuations, corporate growth and turnaround services. Dave is a Certified Business Intermediary (CBI), a licensed business broker, and a member of IBBA and the MBBI. Contact (630) 325-0123, davekauppi@midmarkcap.com or www.midmarkcap.com.

 

Internal Revenue Service
The US government agency responsible for tax collection and tax law enforcement. Includes income tax forms, instructions, and agency publications.
www.irs.gov
 
Tax Information for Individuals
Access to useful information, booklets and other tools from the Internal Revenue Service.
www.irs.gov
 
Tax Center - Yahoo! Finance - Tax forms, tips and calculators.
Yahoo! Finance: Tax - Find all the resources you need for tax season. Review recent tax law changes, estimate your taxes, find tax tips and expert answers ...
tax.yahoo.com
 
Taxes: Tax Planning, Tools and Advice - MSN Money
Microsoft's Tax Preparation site, in association with Tax Server.
moneycentral.msn.com
 
Tax - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Governments use different kinds of taxes and vary the tax rates: ... Taxes are most often levied as a percentage, called the tax rate, of a certain value, ...
en.wikipedia.org
 
H&R Block | Taxes, Online Tax Preparation, Tax Software, Filing ...
Offers online and in-person tax preparation and tax software, mortgages, brokerage and financial services, consumer tips and tax planning information.
www.hrblock.com
 
TaxCut Online | H&R Block | Online Taxes, File Taxes Online ...
File your Taxes online with TaxCut Online. Learn how to file taxes online here.
www.hrblock.com
 
Income Taxes, Tax Returns, Refunds, Deductions and E-File Software ...
Popular tax preparation software by Intuit. Integrates with Quicken, spreadsheets and offers state by state electronic filing.
turbotax.intuit.com
 
Taxes & Estates, Tax and Estate Planning Advice - Forbes.com
Personal Finance - Get tax and estate planning advice and information from Forbes.com.
www.forbes.com
 
Essential Links to Taxes
TurboTax Premier For Federal Returns 2005 Win/Mac, TurboTax Total Tax Solution Deluxe 2005 with State Win/Mac, TurboTax Basic 2005 Win/Mac... ...
www.el.com
 
Government > Taxes in the Yahoo! Directory
Yahoo! reviewed these sites and found them related to Government > Taxes.
dir.yahoo.com
 
Taxes - Tax News for Home and Business from CNNMoney
The latest in tax law updates, news, forms & advice from CNNMoney.com. Includes a refund savings calculator, and interactive tax lessons.
money.cnn.com
 
The Tax Foundation - Educating Taxpayers Since 1937
Devoted to educating taxpayers about tax policy and the total tax burden borne by Americans at all levels of government.
www.taxfoundation.org
 
Welcome to the Vermont Department of Taxes
Welcome to the Vermont Department of Taxes... ... Changes to Property Tax Adjustments in 2007 - updated 10/18. - Tax Expenditures Transition Report on ...
www.state.vt.us
 
Franchise Tax Board Homepage
The department that collects state personal income taxes and bank and corporation taxes for the State of California. Access to forms and tax information.
www.ftb.ca.gov
 
HM Revenue & Customs: Home Page
News and information on tax and national insurance, including downloadable leaflets and forms and the latest news on filing tax returns on-line.
www.hmrc.gov.uk
 
State and Local Tax
Piper Resources; State Tax Rates and Structure ...Federation of Tax Administrators; State Payroll Taxes Information ...Symmetry Software ...
www.taxsites.com
 
Quicken.com
www.quicken.com/taxes/ - 3k - Cached - Similar pages
 
Tax news and advice from Bankrate.com
Information on all phases of tax planning and preparation.
www.bankrate.com
 
Online Tax Advice - Tax Preparation Help - Income Tax Tips
Income Tax Tips - MarketWatch offers online tax advice and tips. ... IRS inflation adjustments mean tax break on next year's taxes. ...
www.marketwatch.com
 
 

 

Content Menu
  • 10 ways to find the money hiding in your paycheck

  • 1 001 deals and steals a guide to online classifieds

  • 23 things to say when someone wants to pick your brain

  • 33 essential year end financial tasks

  • 4 bulletproof strategies that let real estate professionals cut their federal taxes

  • 4 simple steps to reduce your taxes

  • 50 unbelievable benefits of joint venture marketing

  • 5 magic points should i buy or rent my home

  • 5 things about offshore asset protection every internet marketer should know

  • 5 ways to protect your bond portfolio from rising interest rates

  • 7 cash flow secrets your accountant never told you

  • 7 financial strategies for transitioning from salaried to solo

  • 7 secrets to writing inventory procedures

  • adjustable vs fixed rate mortgages

  • advantages and disadvantages of a reverse mortgage

  • an introduction to incorporating in florida

  • an introduction to taxes how you pay and file

  • are you an innocent victim of these popular myths

  • are you overpaying taxes if you use tax preparation software

  • are you ready to own and operate a business

  • are you tired of tenants toilets and trash

  • auto loans dont dig a money pit in your garage

  • a look at small business incorporating in florida

  • a singles game of real estate

  • a source is a source of course of course

  • bankruptcy basics

  • basic home loan terms explained

  • basic steps to start a laminate flooring business

  • beating taxes inflation

  • begging your trust in africa

  • business or hobby what would the irs call your business

  • buying a business

  • buying new construction how do i begin

  • buying overseas property

  • buy now retire later an investment in your dreams

  • cafeteria plan employee benefit should be another feather in your benefit programs cap

  • can nurses be entrepreneurs

  • chattanooga mortgage

  • child and dependent care credit can help you save on your taxes

  • coming to a business like yours webware

  • conditions are right for buying the higher priced home youve always wanted

  • control health care costs and save taxes

  • corporations failing to claim amt exemption overpay taxes by 11 000

  • corruption and transparency

  • creating time the virtual way how virtual assistants are simplifying life for small business owners

  • credit counseling or bankruptcy which is best for you

  • currencies taxes and citizenship

  • cut your taxes and receive a 5000 refund start a home based business

  • deadlines approaching for filing 1099s for independent contractors

  • death and taxes two certainties of life

  • death taxes

  • death taxes and the non automated phone systems

  • debt settlement income taxes what you need to know

  • debunking the fafsa myth

  • defining a long term investment in the stock market

  • disaster decision do you need insurance

  • dont wait for tax time to look at the bottom line

  • do the hardest thing first and the rest will be easy

  • do your own taxes

  • do you need a financial planner

  • do you pay taxes on ebay income

  • economic survival in the 21st century the three key questions to ask

  • eight ways to consolidate debt

  • email scam warnings

  • employment taxes depositing with the irs

  • employment taxes what are they

  • entrepreneurs ask what can a virtual assistant do for me

  • escrow accounts are you paying too much

  • euro tax haven threat

  • facts of day trading

  • failure to pay employment taxes penalties

  • find the right service to prepare your taxes

  • five tips for first time entrepreneurs

  • five ways to improve your bottom line

  • getting a second extension to file 2004 taxes

  • getting help with your taxes

  • get off to a great start with the right credit card

  • get real about home businesses

  • global communications and offshore company formations

  • going offshore for asset protection

  • go multinational

  • hiring a virtual assistant can help your business grow

  • home based business owners save thousands on their taxes

  • home based business taxes where to find answers

  • home based business tax deductions

  • home based business tax tips

  • home based business your ultimate tax shelter

  • home business legalities and tax advantages

  • home business tax tips

  • how can the average person build wealth in real estate

  • how much do you really need to make as a wahm

  • how to avoid getting disastrously dot conned online

  • how to check the status of your tax refund online

  • how to choose the proper entity for your business

  • how to drive the irs crazy

  • how to get an extension to file your business tax returns

  • how to make good use of spreadsheets

  • how to make the most of an at home money making business opportunity

  • how to maximize your home business tax deductions for 2005

  • how to minimize your taxes on wealth

  • how to qualify a buyer

  • how to raise money for starting a business

  • how to realistically set your fees part 1

  • how to realistically set your fees part 2

  • how to realistically set your fees part 3

  • how to realistically set your fees part 4

  • how to refinance your home

  • how to save taxes with an s corporation

  • how to set up a pre tax insurance cafeteria plan benefit

  • how to start a house cleaning business in 7 simple steps

  • how to start a successful business

  • how to start investing for financial independence part 1

  • how to start investing for financial independence part 2

  • how to start your own business and be successful

  • how to touch the hands of greatness

  • how to turn business losses into cash flow

  • how to use outsourcing to beat your competition

  • hurricane katrina how to use your business loss to get a refund on 2004 taxes

  • identity theft is your business at risk

  • index

  • innocent spouses relief from taxes

  • insiders guide to snaring the best lease deal

  • international shipping freight for dummies

  • international support microsoft great plains var partner selection overview for v p it

  • internet marketing and your old age

  • interview with ron mead the secret goldmine of probate real estate

  • investors avoid these 5 common tax mistakes

  • is 100 annual return on investments possible with low risk land investments

  • is vacation rental ownership your business opportunity

  • is your business idea feasible

  • ive heard about facta what does it mean

  • i cant pay my taxes what do i do

  • i wanna hold your hand first time homebuyers

  • keeping your businesss finances on track

  • keeping your own money not handing it over to the taxman

  • keep more of what you make start a home based business

  • little known tax deductions that can save you big

  • local taxes

  • long term energy outook

  • look past the bottom line for a propertys investment potential

  • look past the bottom line for a propertys potential

  • love the thrill of risk invest in an annuity

  • military reservists enlistees may get deferral of back taxes

  • monaco might lose its status of personal income tax haven

  • my house is the best contest is over

  • my top ten tips for selling travel on ebay

  • negotiating real estate deals to win win

  • new trends create an alternative to hiring employees

  • nine advance networking skills for seasoned networkers

  • no income verification home equity loan

  • nursing shortage here is what some hospitals are doing

  • online home equity loans a basic glossary

  • outsourcing and your business

  • payroll taxes

  • personal training 3 keys to training clients in their homes

  • personnel records the paperwork nightmare

  • preparing for your tax interview the what to bring checklist

  • professional transcription and your business

  • protecting the tax advantage of your deferred compensation

  • real estate auction action buying a home at auction

  • real estate closing costs exposed

  • real estate investors dont close your eyes to closing costs

  • real estate investors remember the impound cash

  • real estate remains a strong investment

  • reducing debt before its too late how to avoid the pitfalls of creeping debt

  • relocating for retirement which realtor can help you

  • review small business taxes made easy

  • rotator

  • rrifs death taxes

  • save money on taxes double your income now with tax saving tips on deductions

  • selling your business a tool to reduce taxes

  • selling your technology company why earnouts make sense today

  • sell a business deal structure and taxes

  • seven key tax deductions for the self employed

  • seven ways to save on taxes next year

  • shocking experienced copywriter reveals little known secrets to closing big ticket deals

  • single and multi owner llc taxes

  • small business tax deductions for year end 2004

  • small business tax tips product review of tax reduction toolkit

  • small business valuation primer

  • so you want to be a freelancer heres how

  • starting a business what new and existing business owners should know

  • state taxes

  • student credit cards 101

  • student home purchase plan

  • success tip making your business look bigger to your customers

  • survey says telecommuting ranks high on job seekers list

  • take back your time

  • taxes as a competitive advantage in the global economy

  • taxes made easy for your home based business

  • taxes taxes taxes who really pays the most

  • tax advantages in a home business

  • tax trap 1 waiting to incorporate what a difference a date can make

  • ten steps to mlm success

  • ten ways to become a mulitmillionaire

  • the 8 biggest mistakes when designing portfolios and how to avoid them

  • the basics of business record keeping

  • the benefits of incorporating in florida

  • the benefits of incorporating your business

  • the business failed but did you

  • the cost of going public in the united states

  • the millionaires favorite author

  • the most overlooked way to legally decrease taxes in 2005

  • the secret science of online shopping

  • the seven cs partnership danger signs the 5th c control issues

  • the true cost of self employment

  • things your mother never told you closing costs

  • this year try using tax software to file your taxes

  • tips and simple guidelines on how to calculate payroll taxes

  • top 10 things to consider on home loans

  • truly bizarre taxes the tax on illegal drugs

  • uncle sam is ready are you organizing tips for tax time

  • understanding employee taxes

  • understanding financial statements when approaching lenders

  • use your cell phone trial period to test your plan here are some guidelines

  • venture leasing a smarter way to build enterprise value

  • virtual assistance a money saving opportunity for employers

  • virtual assistance for healthcare professionals

  • wealth creation and mortgage planning two great tastes that taste great together

  • whats it worth

  • what are the taxes on earnings

  • what does extending your taxes mean to you

  • what is a home based travel agent

  • what is the best entity

  • what is the key to slashing your taxes

  • what to expect in closing costs on a home purchase

  • who wants to be a millionaire

  • why a collection agency is your small businesss best friend

  • why does facta matter to me

  • why one should chose a network marketing home base

  • why pay taxes see how not to just kidding

  • why small businesses fail or fail to thrive

  • why to start business in ukraine

  • why work from home

  • working with your real estate attorney

  • work from home in 3 easy steps

  • year end tax planning and preparation for businesses tax tips for 2004